For almost twenty-two years I spoke with a profound speech impediment. Born without a soft palate, I lacked the physical equipment needed to make a proper “s” sound. Everything I said had a nasal quality, and the “s” was entirely unrecognizable.
When you’re talking, your soft palate is supposed to close off the nasal cavity and channels your breath out through your mouth. My breath just kept traveling up into and then out of my nose. I had no way to stop it.

Speaking in public filled me with dread, especially around strangers. Bullies had antagonized me for years, people often treated me as mentally disabled, and a few adults were plainly unkind. For instance, one teacher had told me several times to repeat myself when I was explaining my work. Finally, she said, “Come back when you learn to talk.”
These everyday experiences left me feeling like I was on the outside looking in. I developed a persistent spiritual ache. A loneliness laced with cynicism and bitterness.
Just before my twenty-second birthday I went under the knife for six hours of reconstructive surgery. As a result of the operation, I spoke normally within days. My spiritual ache? That took longer. And it wasn’t the medical procedure that started mending my soul. Faith is doing that. Or to be more precise, my relationship with the risen Christ has been making me whole.
Sometimes people define faith as asserting the correct doctrines, adhering to a strict set of moral principles, and sincerely participating in the approved spiritual practices. Don’t get me wrong. There’s an important role in the life of faith for doctrine, morality, and worship. But it’s important to remember what that role is.

We don’t recite creeds, behave ethically, and spend time praying in order to win God over. They are not achievements we hope to trade for a divine reward. God’s love for us is not transactional. It’s never a response to what how we think or what we do. In fact, this gets the cart before the horse.
They are our responses to God’s initiative, marks of our openness to God’s unrelenting, unearned love for us. Nadia Bolz-Weber put it like this. “The movement in our relationship to God is always from God to us. Always. We can’t, through our piety or goodness, move closer to God. God is always coming near to us.” (Pastrix, p. 49)
Theology is the community’s reflection upon the divine self-revelation. We obey the moral law out of love for God and love of neighbor. In worship we give ourselves back to the one who loved us first. To roughly paraphrase Richard Rohr, the life of faith is not about changing God’s mind about us. It’s about letting God’s love for us change who we are right down to our toes.
Detractors once criticized Jesus for rubbing elbows with sinners. Here’s what he said in response: “Go and learn what this means, ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’ For I have come to call not the righteous but sinners.” (Matthew 9:13) He’s echoing the Law and the Prophets. For instance, Hosea said, “I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings.” (Hosea 6:6)
It’s entirely possible to insist on the truth of a set of doctrines because we like to be right. Moral codes can be used to control others. And worship can be an insincere social gesture. Jesus is telling us that the life of faith is about love. God loves us. In response to that love, disciples love God and love neighbor.

People sometimes ask me why I believe in Jesus in the first place. I frequently answer by saying that I’ve come to see that Jesus believes in me. He believed in me when my cynicism and my bitterness prevented me from loving him and obscured from me the ache in the souls around me. He keeps showing up in my life even when I get too busy or distracted or self-absorbed to show up for him.
Over time, his unwavering love has mostly freed me from cynicism and bitterness. Every now and then that old feeling that I’m on the outside looking in creeps back in. Jesus’ love reminds me that, in him, there are no insiders or outsiders. There’s just God’s beloved.
Let me be honest, I need that reminder. And while I’m at it, I admit that I need an additional reminder. Each person I meet is God’s beloved. Clearly, some people will not act like. Mercy is all about acting like I can still see the face of Jesus in them, even when they can’t see it in themselves.

Okay, it’s not so easy to show mercy to people who hate, to people who intentionally harm others, or to people who gleefully enrich themselves at the expense of others. But let me tell you something that a friend once told me.
A meth addict had barged into a worship service she was leading. He was loud, disruptive, and threatening. After a couple of minutes, he stormed back out, slamming the door behind him. She prayed, “Well, Jesus, you better show me what you love about this guy. Because I’m sure not seeing it.”
It’s a good prayer. And I’ve added a phrase since I first heard it. “Help me remember that somebody has probably said this prayer about me.”
This week I’m beginning a new thing here at the blog. I’ll be reflecting (mostly) on Scripture lessons a week or so in advance. I hope that this may be helpful in sermon prep for my preaching friends. This essay draws on the readings for Proper 5 Year A of the Revised Common Lectionary.
Your honesty and saying things like they are inspire us, Bishop. Keep it up. Stephen Waller
Beautiful. Thank you for this.
Thanks from one of your preaching friends. Still have appreciation for the retreat you led for us in Great Bend Kansas at the Dominican Sisters Convent.
I remember it fondly
“On the outside looking in.” A clear description of how life has been for me so much of the time.
Clearly an introvert, I am responsible for most of the time being out there instead of in there.
I like it that you’re not trying to get me to give up my reserve. I do like it that you are talking about Jesus and, by extension, God’s mercy and welcome.
Somebody once wisely said, “If you feel distant from God, who moved?”
Blessing to you my fellow introvert and friend
Excellent piece! I really needed this right now. I still struggle with transactional theology even though I don’t believe it! Thanks for your good work! Peace.
Thank you so much. I am glad that this piece has been helpful.
I am sad for the young Jacob. Long ago I said something similar to a student, but it was about grammar. “Come back when you can put periods at the end of your sentences.” Geez, I am ashamed of that comment. This child wanted me to read what she wrote and I blasted her chances of becoming a better writer. I am better now. Age does that. I see children every day who are not yet their best selves. We have to see that Jesus is working in them, too. Give them grace. Thanks for your witness to God’s love.
Knowing you as I do, I suspect that you’re being pretty hard on yourself. Your kindness and compassion are so very clear to me. But I also know that you’ve learned much over the years. No wonder you’re a marvelous teacher
Really excited about your new approach with scripture lessons! And, you know? I think we gain so much in compassion, understanding, empathy, love, and courage for others through our own experiences of being outsiders.
💙💙 True that
The hardest thing Jesus asks of us is to love the unlovable, extend justice to the unjust, and respect the disrespectful, but that is precisely Jesus way and we are called to that if we profess to be his disciples. If I want to live in a world of kindness and caring, then that is how I need to live.
Amen to that
Mercy received and mercy given our extremely special gifts. Thank you for the reminder.