When Fragile Things Shatter

Fragile things break easily. Especially human things.

The glass shattered before I realized what was happening. Bustling about in the kitchen, I had knocked it to the floor while reaching for some spices and watching a timer and listening to “All Things Considered.” Menacing shards jutted up where I stood. Tiny slivers had scattered to all corners of the room.

Our children were very young. They dashed in with bare feet to investigate the noise. “Stop! Hold it right there!” I shouted.

Before letting anyone else cross the kitchen threshold, I picked up the largest pieces of glass. Next came a furious sweeping of smaller bits. Finally, I vacuumed the floor over and over to get rid of the tiny, invisible grains lying in wait for tender little feet.

Fragile things shatter so easily.

A37312DC-B5EF-4336-B8E9-524E2CA69141Breaking that glass inconvenienced me. I tossed the jagged remains into the trash without a second thought. One mass-produced drinking glass looks pretty much like another. Amazon offers tons of replacements.

By contrast, had I dropped my maternal grandmother’s china tea set, I would have frantically gathered up every delicate piece. There could be no replacement.

Even in the unlikely event that I could order another set by the same manufacturer in the Czech Republic, it would not be my grandmother’s tea set. The pot from which she poured tea with her work-weary old hands. The cups she had somehow rescued and brought with her from war-ravaged Austria.

I would want desperately to fix it. And yet, despite my best efforts, I would never be able to make that tea set whole again. Sure, I could clean up the mess. Maybe I would be tempted to hang on to a bag of broken pieces. I would feel the tea set’s loss and wish again and again that I hadn’t broken it. I would wish that, somehow, what I had broken could be mended.

Fragile things break easily. Especially human things. Human lives. Human souls. Human hearts. Human things are not interchangeable. They are not replaceable. They can only be mended. Frequently, they are beyond our ability to mend on our own.

Each of us lives with things we’ve broken and cannot mend. Many of us contend with the breakage that another person has caused in our lives. All of us were thrown into a world already broken by racism, sexual harassment, sexism, poverty, intolerance, economic exploitation, and escalating violence.

8E6E72D0-3FC5-4871-A095-D6B2A18A2F2AIf our hearts and minds are genuinely open to the ache in our own hearts and the misery around the world, we will also recognize a deep yearning that all things—all the fragile, human things—be made whole. But arriving at that genuine openness makes us terribly vulnerable. We begin to see that we yearn for something that we need divine help to achieve.

So, many of us avoid that openness by focusing narrowly on our own comforts and status. We anesthetize ourselves with luxuries, applause, entertainments, sex, power, or chemicals. This life-strategy will temporarily prevent the misery of others from encroaching on our personal enjoyments. But eventually the fractures within our own souls begin to catch up with us.

Oh, we may continue to employ these strategies more and more frantically right into the grave. But loneliness will haunt us. Our own misery will grow as we vaguely realize how increasingly unstable, unattractive, and narcissistic we appear to everyone around us.

Before reaching such an extreme state of disintegration, most of us begin to identify our deep longing for wholeness. We become willing to do something about it. To put that another way, we allow ourselves to be susceptible to outrageous hope.

I believe that it was this kind of susceptibility to hope that drew so many people into the wilderness to listen to John the Baptist.

If you ask people for a word association with John the Baptist—excluding references to clothing and dietary habits—you’re likely to hear the word “repentance” again and again. And for good reason. He preached about and offered a baptism for repentance of sins. But I wonder if we hear what he’s actually trying to tell us.

ED9D9A4B-5EE2-42B1-BCBC-23CFE5FF1DA9Many of us assume that he’s telling people that they’ve broken the rules. God is coming back soon to judge the good and the evil. Say you’re sorry and change your ways, and you’ll dodge the perdition bullet.

The Gospel according to Mark leaves a different impression. Mark prefaces his story about the Baptizer with a word from the prophet Isaiah: prepare. He doesn’t mean, “Gussy up so you’ll make the cut on judgment day.” Instead, he’s saying something like this: let’s make ourselves open to mending. The first step is to admit that we need it.

The Baptizer’s call to repentance is an invitation to acknowledge the world’s brokenness, our role in the brokenness, and the suffering and sorrow that result from that brokenness. That’s as far as John the Baptist can take us. He tells us openly that another will come after him to bring what he cannot give.

That other has come. Most of us realize that he meant Jesus. But he was also pointing at us. Jesus began the mending of shattered fragile things. He continues it through fragile hands and feet like yours and mine.


  1. So poignant– so many women I know broken by harassment and abuse – often when they went seeking mending. Some by bishops even. Hoping the House of Bishops gets serious about cleaning house and making amends.


  2. We often need to be reminded how fragile we all are. Your words remind me of Edward Roland Sill’s poem, “The Fool’s Prayer,” specifically these verses:

    “These clumsy feet, still in the mire,
    Go crushing blossoms without end;
    These hard, well-meaning hands we thrust
    Among the heart-strings of a friend.

    “The ill-timed truth we might have kept— 25
    Who knows how sharp it pierced and stung?
    The word we had not sense to say—
    Who knows how grandly it had rung?”

    Thanks for the reminder!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Your piece has been the most perfect gateway into Christmas for me this year. Thank you. The acknowledgment of pain, of brokenness, of the need for wholeness is critical for our even beginning to receive the gift of Christmas. I am grateful for the refuge of your words, your own tender experience, the invitation to begin to articulate my own. There is a very real temptation, in these days of extreme political angst, to avoid paying attention the ordinary pain we experience daily which, by year’s end, really piles up–the personal pain of simply living in a human body, in a human family, in a human self. The fracturing of our culture and global ecology only intensifies the pain we feel in our private lives, fractures the unconscious sense of wholeness we might hope to carry around with us day to day. I feel very small in this world, and yet the pain I feel is great. No real reason except that I am human. I am unglued, hollow, helpless, hopeless. I do not see the end of all this. I do not see the end of anything except that I am hollow and alone … and that is ok. It is ok because I can say it, write it here, and hope for another to hear me. To hear that these words ring true, that they are mine, they are yours, they are ours. Merry Christmas, as we begin, now, to put our lives back together. Together.


    1. Thank you for this lovely reflection in response to my post. I’m grateful that my words provided a refuge and extended an invitation. I checked out your blog and noticed that you’ve gone a while without posting. I hope you’ll resume sharing your gift or direct me to another site that you now use. Merry Christmas. And yes, let it be a time of putting lives back together.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. And thank you for your kind comments, as well. As you noticed, I haven’t written in my blog in a while. Just sort of lost interest/energy in writing in that venue. It began to take a lot of energy to write so openly and honestly, in a way that I couldn’t seem to replenish. The last couple of years have been hard for me; a number of losses and the onset of menopause have rocked me with anxiety, insomnia, and a feeling of being lost in the world. In the midst of this, I have grown reluctant to write about all the dark things publicly, Many people seem turned off by too much preoccupation with brokenness and grief; moreover, I have feared that writing so openly would take me deeper into darkness and isolation. All that said, I very much appreciate your interest. I do write some poetry on Facebook, believe it or not, and I’d be happy to “friend” you in that venue. If you have a FB page, please send me a Friend Request. I will hope to read more of your blogs, too. Your words and gentle spirit really touched me. Thank you, again.


          1. I sent you a message through your FB page just now. Didn’t realize you weren’t picking up my name. (I’ve been out of the blog world for a while.) I don’t see a way to send you a Friend Req for some reason, maybe because you’re id’ed as a Public Figure? Let me know if you get the message!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.